Editorial Policies and Peer Review Process
MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi is committed to maintaining high standards of editorial integrity, scientific quality, transparency, and fairness. The journal's editorial and peer-review procedures are designed to ensure that submitted manuscripts are evaluated objectively, efficiently, and rigorously by researchers with appropriate expertise. Editorial decisions are based on the scientific merit, originality, methodological soundness, relevance, and ethical integrity of submitted work.
Manuscript Submission
All manuscripts must be submitted to: contact.mycoindia@gmail.com. Submissions sent directly to individual editors may be redirected to the official submission system to ensure appropriate tracking and transparent editorial handling.
Initial Submission Format
To ensure consistency and facilitate efficient editorial assessment, MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi requires all manuscripts to be formatted according to the journal’s prescribed style at the time of initial submission. Authors must carefully follow the MycoIndia Author Guidelines and prepare their manuscript using the official MycoIndia Manuscript Template (Also available in PDF format), which specifies the required organization and presentation of manuscript elements, including the title page, abstract, keywords, main text, figures, tables, declarations, and references.
Manuscripts that do not conform to the journal’s formatting and submission requirements may be returned to the authors for correction before editorial evaluation. Authors should therefore ensure that all required information is complete, that figures and tables are appropriately prepared and cited, that references follow the prescribed journal style, and that any relevant supplementary materials are included before submission. The template also provides the required structure for sections such as Introduction, Materials and methods, Results, Discussion, Acknowledgement, Competing interests, and References.
Required Documents
A complete submission should normally include:
A cover letter
The complete manuscript
Figures and tables, either embedded in the manuscript or supplied separately
References
Supplementary material, where applicable
A statement describing each author's contribution
A declaration of conflicts of interest
Funding information, where applicable
Data availability information, where applicable
Appropriate ethical or regulatory statements, where required
Authors are responsible for ensuring that all listed authors have approved the submitted version of the manuscript and consented to its submission to MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi.
Peer Review Process
MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi follows a single-blind peer-review process. Under this model, the identities of the authors are normally known to reviewers, while the identities of reviewers remain confidential during the review process. Reviewer identities may only be disclosed where permitted by journal policy and with the explicit consent of the reviewer. The peer-review process generally consists of the following stages.
1. Initial Editorial Assessment
Following submission, each manuscript undergoes an initial assessment by the Editorial Office or an appropriate editor.
The initial evaluation may consider:
Relevance to the aims and scope of the journal
Scientific quality and originality
Completeness of the submission
Clarity and organization of the manuscript
Compliance with basic ethical and publication requirements
Potential plagiarism, duplicate publication, or redundant publication
Appropriateness of the methodology and study design
Suitability for external peer review
Manuscripts that fall outside the journal's scope, do not meet minimum scientific or ethical standards, or are otherwise unsuitable for consideration may be declined without external peer review. Such decisions are intended to prevent unnecessary delays for authors and reviewers.
2. Assignment to a Handling Editor
Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial assessment are assigned to a Handling Editor or another appropriate member of the Editorial Board with expertise relevant to the subject of the manuscript. The Handling Editor oversees the peer-review process, identifies suitable reviewers, evaluates reviewer reports, and provides an editorial recommendation. Editors must disclose any potential conflict of interest that could affect their impartial handling of a manuscript.
3. Selection and Invitation of Reviewers
The Handling Editor normally seeks evaluations from at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise.
Reviewers are selected on the basis of factors including:
Subject expertise
Relevant research and publication experience
Ability to provide an objective scientific assessment
Absence of inappropriate conflicts of interest
Previous reviewing performance, where known
The journal seeks to avoid reviewers who have recent collaborations, close personal or professional relationships, institutional conflicts, or other relationships with the authors that could reasonably compromise the independence of the review. Authors may be permitted to suggest potential reviewers or identify individuals they prefer not to review their manuscript. Such requests are considered by the editors but are not binding.
4. Reviewer Evaluation
Reviewers are requested to assess the manuscript critically and constructively. Evaluation may include consideration of:
Originality and scientific significance
Relevance to mycology and the scope of the journal
Adequacy of sampling and experimental design
Appropriateness of analytical or taxonomic methods
Reliability of data and interpretations
Validity of conclusions
Quality of figures, tables, and supporting information
Accuracy and completeness of taxonomic and nomenclatural treatment
Adequacy of molecular, phylogenetic, ecological, or other supporting evidence
Appropriate citation of previous literature
Ethical and research-integrity considerations
Reviewers provide confidential comments to the editor where appropriate, comments for the authors, and an editorial recommendation. Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The final publication decision remains with the journal's editors.
Editorial Decisions
Following consideration of the reviewer reports and the Handling Editor's recommendation, the Editor-in-Chief, Managing Editor, or another authorized senior editor makes the editorial decision.
Possible decisions include:
Acceptance - The manuscript is considered suitable for publication without substantial further scientific changes. Minor editorial or production corrections may still be required.
Minor Revision - The manuscript requires relatively limited changes before it can be considered for acceptance.
Major Revision - The manuscript requires substantial scientific, methodological, taxonomic, analytical, or presentational changes before it can be reconsidered. A decision of major revision does not guarantee subsequent acceptance.
Rejection - The manuscript is considered unsuitable for publication in MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi because of concerns relating to scope, originality, scientific quality, methodology, interpretation, ethics, or other substantive matters.
Author Revisions
When revisions are requested, authors should submit:
A revised manuscript
A detailed point-by-point response to all reviewer and editor comments
A clear indication of changes made to the manuscript
An explanation for any reviewer recommendation that has not been followed
Authors are normally expected to submit revised manuscripts within the period specified in the editorial decision letter. Where appropriate, authors may request additional time by contacting the Editorial Office before the revision deadline. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers or evaluated directly by the Handling Editor, depending on the extent and nature of the revisions.
Editorial Timelines and Communication
MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi aims to provide authors with timely editorial decisions while maintaining a rigorous peer-review process. The time required for review may vary depending on the subject area, availability of qualified reviewers, complexity of the manuscript, and extent of revisions required. As a general target, the journal aims to complete the initial peer-review and editorial decision process within approximately 8–10 weeks, although some manuscripts may require additional time. Authors who have not received an editorial update within approximately 60 days of submission may contact the Editorial Office for information regarding the status of their manuscript.
Editorial contact: contact.mycoindia@gmail.com
Post-Acceptance and Publication
Proofing
Following acceptance and production, the corresponding author will normally receive page proofs or a formatted version of the article for final checking.
Authors are responsible for reviewing the proof carefully for:
Typographical errors
Formatting problems
Errors in author names or affiliations
Problems with figures or tables
Errors introduced during production
Corrections should be returned within the period specified by the Editorial Office. Substantial changes to the scientific content, authorship, data, results, interpretation, or conclusions are normally not permitted at the proof stage unless approved by the editor.
Publication
Once the final proof has been approved and all publication requirements have been completed, the article will be published on the official MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi website.
Journal website: mycoindia.org
As an open-access journal, published articles are made freely available online to readers without subscription or access charges.
Transparency in Peer Review
MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi supports transparency and appropriate recognition of editorial and peer-review contributions while protecting reviewer confidentiality. The name of the Handling Editor may be published with the final article. Reviewer names may be acknowledged only where the reviewer has provided explicit consent and where disclosure is consistent with the journal's peer-review policy. Review reports and author responses will not normally be published unless the journal formally adopts an open peer-review policy.
Editorial Independence
Editorial decisions are made independently of financial, institutional, personal, or commercial interests. Editors are expected to assess submissions solely on their scientific quality, relevance, originality, methodological rigor, and compliance with ethical and editorial requirements. The journal's owners, sponsors, supporting institutions, or donors must not improperly influence individual editorial decisions.
Conflicts of Interest
Authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose relationships or interests that could reasonably be perceived as influencing their judgment.
Potential conflicts may include:
Financial relationships
Employment relationships
Institutional relationships
Recent research collaborations
Personal or professional relationships
Academic competition
Intellectual or ideological conflicts directly related to the submitted work
Disclosure of a conflict does not necessarily prevent participation in the publication process. However, editors may reassign a manuscript or reviewer where a conflict could compromise, or reasonably appear to compromise, editorial independence.
Manuscripts Submitted by Editors or Editorial Board Members
Manuscripts submitted by the Editor-in-Chief, Managing Editor, members of the Editorial Board, journal founders, journal staff, or other individuals involved in journal governance will not receive preferential treatment. Such manuscripts will be assigned to an independent editor who has no relevant conflict of interest with the authors.
The submitting editor or board member will not participate in:
Selection of reviewers
Access to confidential reviewer identities beyond what is normally permitted
Assessment of reviewer reports
Editorial deliberations concerning the manuscript
The final publication decision
The manuscript will undergo the same peer-review and editorial standards applied to other submissions.
Reviewer Confidentiality
Reviewers must treat submitted manuscripts and associated materials as confidential documents.
Reviewers must not:
Share manuscripts without editorial permission
Use unpublished data or ideas for personal advantage
Contact authors directly regarding the manuscript without permission
Upload confidential manuscripts to unauthorized external services or systems where confidentiality cannot be assured
Information obtained through peer review must not be used before publication without appropriate authorization.
Corrections, Addenda, and Retractions
MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi is committed to maintaining the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record. When a significant error is identified after publication, the journal will determine the appropriate corrective action according to the nature and severity of the problem.
Possible actions include:
Correction or Corrigendum - A formal correction may be published when an error affects part of an article but does not invalidate the principal findings or conclusions. The correction will be linked to the original article wherever technically possible.
Addendum - An addendum may be published where important supplementary information or clarification needs to be formally associated with a published article.
Expression of Concern - An expression of concern may be issued when serious questions have been raised regarding a published article but the available evidence is insufficient to justify immediate correction or retraction, or where an investigation is ongoing.
Retraction - An article may be retracted when there is reliable evidence that its findings are seriously unreliable, when research or publication misconduct has materially affected the work, when substantial plagiarism or redundant publication is established, or where other serious ethical or legal concerns require withdrawal of the article from the scholarly record. Retraction notices will state the reason for the retraction and, where appropriate, identify who initiated the retraction. Retracted articles should remain part of the scholarly record and be clearly identified as retracted rather than being silently removed, except in exceptional circumstances involving legal, privacy, or safety considerations.
Complaints and Appeals
Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they believe that a significant scientific, procedural, or factual error affected the decision. Appeals should provide a clear explanation of the grounds for reconsideration and should address the substantive issues raised during review. Appeals are normally evaluated by an editor who was not solely responsible for the original decision whenever practicable. Complaints concerning editorial conduct, peer review, publication ethics, or journal procedures may be submitted to the Editorial Office. The journal will consider complaints objectively and confidentially and will seek to resolve them in accordance with established scholarly publishing principles.
Publication Integrity
MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi takes allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously.
Potential concerns may include:
Plagiarism
Data fabrication or falsification
Image manipulation
Duplicate or redundant publication
Undisclosed conflicts of interest
Inappropriate authorship
Citation manipulation
Peer-review manipulation
Misrepresentation of specimens, cultures, sequences, or datasets
Ethical or regulatory violations
Where concerns arise, the journal may request explanations, original data, specimen information, laboratory records, sequence information, ethical approvals, or other relevant documentation. Editorial action will be determined on the basis of the available evidence and the seriousness of the concern.