As a member of the editorial team of MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi, an editor’s primary responsibility is to safeguard the quality, credibility, and integrity of the scholarly record. Editors are entrusted with the fair and rigorous evaluation of submitted manuscripts and are responsible for ensuring that editorial decisions are based on scientific merit, originality, methodological soundness, relevance, and ethical compliance. Editors must manage the peer-review process impartially, maintain confidentiality, protect editorial independence, and uphold the journal’s policies on research and publication ethics.
Manuscript Handling and Peer Review
Fairness and Objectivity
Editors must evaluate all submitted manuscripts fairly and impartially. Editorial consideration must not be influenced by characteristics unrelated to the scientific content of the manuscript, including:
Nationality
Geographic origin
Institutional affiliation
Gender
Race or ethnicity
Religion
Political beliefs
Academic seniority
Personal or professional status
Manuscripts should be assessed primarily on their:
Scientific quality
Originality
Methodological rigor
Clarity
Relevance to the aims and scope of MycoIndia
Reliability of the evidence presented
Compliance with ethical and publication standards
Initial Editorial Assessment
Editors may conduct an initial assessment before sending a manuscript for external peer review.
The initial assessment should consider:
Whether the manuscript falls within the journal’s scope
Whether the research question is scientifically relevant
Whether the study meets minimum standards of scientific quality
Whether the manuscript is sufficiently complete for evaluation
Whether essential data, figures, tables, or supporting information are present
Whether there are obvious ethical or publication concerns
Whether the manuscript substantially duplicates previously published work
Whether the work is suitable for external peer review
Manuscripts that clearly fall outside the journal’s scope or fail to meet minimum scientific or ethical standards may be declined without external review. Such decisions should be based on identifiable scholarly or editorial grounds rather than arbitrary considerations.
Assignment and Management of Peer Review
Editors are responsible for ensuring that manuscripts undergoing external review receive a fair, timely, and appropriately rigorous evaluation.
This responsibility includes:
Identifying reviewers with suitable expertise
Avoiding inappropriate conflicts of interest
Seeking independent assessments
Providing reviewers with appropriate guidance
Monitoring the progress of the review
Evaluating the quality and relevance of reviewer reports
Ensuring that reviewer comments are professional and constructive
MycoIndia normally seeks reports from at least two suitably qualified independent reviewers where external peer review is required.
Selection of Reviewers
Reviewers should be selected on the basis of their expertise and ability to provide an independent assessment of the manuscript.
Editors should consider:
Subject expertise
Relevant publication record
Experience with appropriate methodologies
Knowledge of the taxonomic or ecological group under study
Potential conflicts of interest
Previous review quality and reliability, where known
For specialized manuscripts involving fungal taxonomy, phylogenetics, nomenclature, ecology, genomics, metabolites, conservation, or other technical areas, editors should seek reviewers with appropriate domain expertise. Editors should avoid reviewers who have relationships with the authors that could reasonably compromise independence.
Reviewer Suggestions Provided by Authors
Authors may be permitted to suggest potential reviewers or identify individuals whom they prefer not to review their manuscript. Editors are not required to use author-suggested reviewers. When considering suggested reviewers, editors should independently verify:
Identity
Institutional affiliation
Contact information
Relevant expertise
Potential conflicts of interest
Editors should remain alert to attempts to manipulate the peer-review process through fabricated reviewer identities, false email addresses, inappropriate reviewer suggestions, or coordinated reviewing arrangements.
Quality of Reviewer Reports
Editors should critically assess reviewer reports rather than automatically following reviewer recommendations.
Reports containing:
Personal criticism
Discriminatory remarks
Unprofessional language
Unsupported allegations
Coercive citation requests
Irrelevant demands
Clear conflicts of interest
should not be relied upon without appropriate editorial scrutiny. Where necessary, editors may request clarification, disregard inappropriate comments, seek an additional review, or remove unacceptable remarks before communicating comments to authors.
Confidentiality
All submitted manuscripts and associated editorial materials are confidential. Editors must not disclose manuscript information to individuals who are not legitimately involved in the editorial or peer-review process. Confidential materials may include:
Manuscript files
Supplementary information
Author correspondence
Reviewer identities
Reviewer reports
Editorial deliberations
Unpublished datasets
Figures and images
Sequence information
Research ideas and interpretations
Editors must not use unpublished information obtained through the editorial process for their own research, professional advantage, financial benefit, or the benefit of others.
Use of Artificial Intelligence
Editors must protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts. Unpublished manuscripts, reviewer reports, confidential correspondence, identifiable author information, or other protected editorial material should not be uploaded to generative AI systems or external tools where confidentiality, data protection, or intellectual property cannot be assured. Editors remain fully responsible for all editorial assessments and decisions. Automated or AI-assisted tools must not replace independent scientific and editorial judgment.
Editorial Decisions
Basis for Decisions
Editorial decisions should be based on the overall scientific and ethical evaluation of a manuscript.
Relevant factors may include:
Scientific importance
Originality
Methodological quality
Strength of supporting evidence
Reliability of the results
Validity of the conclusions
Quality of presentation
Relevance to the journal’s scope
Reviewer reports
Author responses
Compliance with ethical and publication requirements
The number or direction of reviewer recommendations should not be treated as a simple vote. Editors are expected to exercise independent scholarly judgment.
Available Editorial Decisions
Depending on the journal’s editorial workflow, decisions may include:
Accept - The manuscript is suitable for publication, subject only to editorial or production requirements.
Minor Revision - The manuscript requires limited changes before it can be considered for acceptance.
Major Revision - Substantial changes are required before the manuscript can be reconsidered. A major revision decision does not guarantee subsequent acceptance.
Reject - The manuscript is not considered suitable for publication because of significant concerns relating to scientific quality, methodology, interpretation, originality, scope, ethics, or other substantive issues.
Editorial Independence
Editors must make decisions independently of inappropriate external influence. Editorial decisions must not be determined by:
Commercial interests
Financial considerations
Institutional pressure
Personal relationships
Donor or sponsor influence
Author reputation or seniority
Geographic origin
Citation potential
Expected publicity
The journal’s publisher, sponsors, donors, supporting institutions, or other external parties must not improperly interfere with individual editorial decisions.
Conflicts of Interest
Editors must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest that could reasonably affect their impartiality. Potential conflicts may include:
Recent collaboration with an author
Employment at the same institution
Supervisory relationships
Personal relationships
Academic competition
Financial interests
Consultancy arrangements
Intellectual property interests
Involvement in closely related research
Significant professional disputes
Where a relevant conflict exists, the editor must recuse themselves from handling the manuscript. The manuscript should then be reassigned to another qualified and independent editor.
Manuscripts Submitted by Editors or Editorial Board Members
Manuscripts submitted by the Editor-in-Chief, Managing Editor, Handling Editors, Editorial Board members, journal founders, or journal staff must not receive preferential treatment. Such manuscripts should be managed independently. The submitting individual must not participate in:
Selection of the Handling Editor
Selection of reviewers
Access to confidential reviewer identities beyond normal journal policy
Evaluation of reviewer reports
Editorial deliberations
The final decision
The manuscript should be assigned to an independent editor with no relevant conflict of interest and should undergo the same standards of peer review as other submissions.
Managing Reviewer Conflicts of Interest
Editors are responsible for assessing potential reviewer conflicts of interest. Reviewers should not normally be selected where there is a relationship that could reasonably affect objectivity, including:
Recent collaboration
Shared institutional affiliation
Close personal relationship
Supervisory relationship
Direct professional rivalry
Financial interest in the outcome
Where uncertainty exists, editors should seek disclosure from the reviewer before proceeding.
Upholding Publication Ethics
MycoIndia follows recognized principles of responsible scholarly publishing and uses guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) where appropriate. Editors are expected to be familiar with the journal’s policies concerning:
Plagiarism
Duplicate publication
Data fabrication and falsification
Image manipulation
Authorship disputes
Conflicts of interest
Peer-review manipulation
Citation manipulation
Corrections
Expressions of concern
Retractions
Complaints and appeals
Following COPE guidance should not be represented as formal COPE membership unless such membership has been separately confirmed.
Suspected Research or Publication Misconduct
Editors have a responsibility to respond appropriately when credible concerns arise regarding possible misconduct. Examples include:
Plagiarism
Data fabrication
Data falsification
Image manipulation
Duplicate publication
Undisclosed conflicts of interest
Authorship misconduct
Citation manipulation
Peer-review manipulation
Fabricated reviewer identities
Misrepresentation of fungal specimens or cultures
Fabricated or unreliable sequence data
Misrepresentation of permits or ethical approvals
Concerns should not be ignored merely because a manuscript has already been published.
Handling Allegations of Misconduct
When potential misconduct is identified, editors should:
Maintain confidentiality
Avoid premature conclusions
Document the concern
Review available evidence
Seek clarification from the authors where appropriate
Request supporting data or documentation when necessary
Consult independent experts when appropriate
Follow relevant journal procedures and COPE guidance
Refer matters to institutions or competent authorities when an investigation exceeds the journal’s remit
Editors should distinguish between honest error, poor research practice, misunderstanding, and deliberate misconduct.
Use of COPE Guidance
Where appropriate, editors should consult relevant COPE flowcharts, decision trees, discussion documents, or guidance when addressing publication ethics concerns. COPE resources may assist editors in handling issues such as:
Suspected plagiarism
Duplicate publication
Authorship disputes
Fabricated data
Peer-review manipulation
Undisclosed conflicts
Requests for retraction
Complaints concerning editorial conduct
Final editorial action should be evidence-based, proportionate, and consistent with the circumstances of the case.
Correcting the Scholarly Record
Editors share responsibility for maintaining the accuracy of the published literature. When significant errors or ethical concerns are identified after publication, appropriate corrective action should be considered.
Possible actions include:
Correction or Corrigendum- Used where an error affects part of an article but does not invalidate its principal findings.
Addendum - Used when important supplementary information or clarification needs to be formally added to the publication record.
Expression of Concern - Used when serious concerns exist but available evidence is incomplete or an investigation is still ongoing.
Retraction - Used when there is reliable evidence that the findings are seriously unreliable or when serious research or publication misconduct has materially compromised the article. Corrective notices should be linked to the original article wherever technically possible.
Retraction Decisions
Retraction should be considered where appropriate for serious concerns such as:
Fabrication
Falsification
Serious plagiarism
Major errors invalidating the principal findings
Duplicate publication
Peer-review manipulation
Serious ethical violations
Unauthorized publication
Other circumstances that fundamentally undermine the reliability or legitimacy of the article
Retraction is intended primarily to correct the scholarly record rather than to punish authors. Retracted articles should normally remain accessible but be clearly identified as retracted.
Appeals
Authors may appeal an editorial decision where they believe that a significant scientific, factual, or procedural error affected the outcome. Editors handling an appeal should consider:
Whether the appeal identifies a substantive error
Whether reviewer comments were interpreted correctly
Whether relevant evidence was overlooked
Whether the original process was fair
Where practicable, an appeal may be reviewed by an editor who was not solely responsible for the original decision. An appeal does not guarantee reconsideration or acceptance.
Complaints Concerning Editors
Complaints concerning the conduct of an editor should not be handled solely by the editor who is the subject of the complaint. Where possible, the matter should be referred to:
The Editor-in-Chief
Managing Editor
Another senior independent editor
An appropriate independent person designated by the journal
Complaints should be assessed fairly, confidentially, and without retaliation against individuals who raise legitimate concerns in good faith.
Communication with Authors
Editors should communicate decisions clearly, respectfully, and professionally. Decision letters should provide sufficient information for authors to understand the reasons for the editorial outcome. Where revisions are requested, editors should help distinguish:
Essential scientific revisions
Important clarifications
Optional suggestions
Minor editorial corrections
Editors should avoid unnecessary rounds of revision and should not require authors to make changes that are scientifically unjustified.
Communication with Reviewers
Editors should provide reviewers with clear instructions and reasonable deadlines. Where appropriate, reviewers may be informed of the final editorial outcome. Editors should recognize that reviewer recommendations are advisory and should avoid placing reviewers in the position of making the final publication decision.
Citation Ethics
Editors must not pressure authors to add citations for the purpose of increasing:
The journal’s citation metrics
The editor’s personal citations
Citations to colleagues
Citations to a particular institution
Requests for additional references must be based on genuine scholarly relevance. Editors should also act if reviewers make excessive or inappropriate self-citation requests.
Special Responsibilities for Taxonomic Manuscripts
Because MycoIndia has a strong focus on fungal diversity and taxonomy, editors handling taxonomic manuscripts should ensure, where relevant, that appropriate expertise is represented during peer review. Editors should consider whether manuscripts provide:
Adequate morphological evidence
Appropriate molecular data
Suitable phylogenetic analyses
Type and voucher information
Culture deposition details where applicable
Sequence accession numbers
Nomenclatural registration information
Comparisons with related taxa
Compliance with applicable nomenclatural requirements
Editors should seek specialist advice where the taxonomic or nomenclatural issues exceed their own expertise.
Timeliness
Editors should make reasonable efforts to manage manuscripts efficiently while preserving the quality of peer review. Editors should:
Invite reviewers promptly
Monitor overdue reviews
Replace unavailable reviewers where appropriate
Avoid unnecessary delays
Communicate significant delays to authors when necessary
Make decisions promptly once sufficient evidence is available
Speed should never take precedence over scientific rigor or ethical integrity.
Contributing to Journal Development
Editors are encouraged to contribute actively to the continued development of MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi. Editorial contributions may include:
Participating in Editorial Board meetings
Reviewing and improving journal policies
Advising on emerging areas of mycological research
Suggesting qualified reviewers and editorial board members
Identifying important topics for reviews or special collections
Promoting good practices in fungal taxonomy and biodiversity research
Encouraging high-quality submissions
Supporting initiatives that improve transparency and reproducibility
Helping strengthen the journal’s national and international scholarly visibility
Any promotional activities must remain separate from individual editorial decisions.
Editorial Accountability
Editors are accountable for applying the journal’s policies consistently and transparently. No editor has authority to override publication ethics, manipulate peer review, or provide preferential treatment to particular authors. Serious or repeated breaches of editorial responsibilities may result in removal from an editorial role following appropriate review by the journal’s leadership.
Commitment to MycoIndia
Editors of MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi are expected to uphold the principles of scientific integrity, editorial independence, fairness, transparency, confidentiality, and accountability. Through rigorous editorial oversight and responsible peer review, the Editorial Board supports the journal’s mission to advance reliable knowledge of fungi, particularly the diversity, taxonomy, systematics, ecology, biology, and conservation of fungi associated with India.
Editorial Office: Dr. Belle Damodara Shenoy, Managing Editor, MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi, CSIR-NIO Regional Centre , 177/1, Opposite Radission Blu Resort, Yendada, Visakhapatnam - 530045, Andhra Pradesh, India
Editorial contact: contact.mycoindia@gmail.com
Website: https://www.mycoindia.org/