Peer reviewers play a central role in maintaining the scientific quality, credibility, and integrity of MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi. By accepting an invitation to review a manuscript, reviewers contribute their subject expertise to the evaluation of scientific merit, methodological rigor, originality, clarity, and relevance. Reviewers also provide constructive feedback that can help authors improve their work and assist editors in making informed publication decisions. MycoIndia greatly values the time, expertise, and professional service contributed by reviewers to the journal and the wider mycological community.
Before Accepting a Review Invitation
Reviewers should carefully consider the following before accepting an invitation.
Expertise: Reviewers should accept an invitation only when the manuscript falls sufficiently within their area of expertise to allow a competent and meaningful assessment. If only part of the manuscript falls within the reviewer's expertise, this should be communicated to the editor. For manuscripts involving specialized areas such as fungal taxonomy, molecular phylogenetics, ecology, nomenclature, metabolite analysis, genomics, or conservation, reviewers should evaluate whether they possess the appropriate expertise to assess the relevant methods and conclusions.
Conflict of Interest: Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest that could affect, or reasonably appear to affect, the objectivity of their review. Potential conflicts may include:
Recent or ongoing collaboration with one or more authors
Employment at the same institution as an author
Close personal or professional relationships
Direct academic competition
Financial interests
Supervisory or student relationships
Significant disagreements or disputes with the authors
Involvement in closely related unpublished work
A conflict of interest does not always prevent an individual from reviewing a manuscript, but it must be disclosed to the editor, who will determine whether the review can proceed. When uncertain, reviewers should contact the Handling Editor before accepting the invitation.
Availability: Reviewers should accept an invitation only if they can reasonably complete the review within the requested timeframe. If a reviewer is unable to meet the deadline, the invitation should be declined promptly so that an alternative reviewer can be invited without unnecessary delay. If unexpected circumstances arise after accepting a review, the reviewer should inform the editor as soon as possible.
Confidentiality and Ethical Responsibilities
Confidentiality: All submitted manuscripts, supplementary files, reviewer communications, and related editorial materials are confidential.
Reviewers must not:
Share the manuscript with unauthorized individuals
Discuss the manuscript with colleagues without permission from the editor
Distribute or reproduce unpublished material
Use unpublished data, ideas, methods, images, sequences, or other information for personal or professional advantage
Contact the authors directly regarding the manuscript unless specifically authorized by the editor
The confidentiality of the manuscript must be maintained throughout and after the review process. If a reviewer believes that consultation with a colleague or specialist would improve the review, permission should first be obtained from the Handling Editor.
Use of Artificial Intelligence During Peer Review
Reviewers must protect the confidentiality of unpublished manuscripts. Confidential manuscripts, reviewer reports, author identities, data, figures, or other unpublished materials must not be uploaded to generative AI systems or external tools where confidentiality, intellectual property, or data security cannot be assured. Reviewers remain fully responsible for the content, accuracy, and integrity of their reports. Automated tools should not replace the reviewer's own expert scientific judgment.
Identifying Potential Misconduct
Reviewers are encouraged to remain alert to possible concerns involving research or publication integrity. These may include:
Plagiarism or inappropriate text reuse
Duplicate or redundant publication
Data fabrication or falsification
Manipulation of images
Misrepresentation of specimens or cultures
Fabricated or unreliable sequence data
Inappropriate authorship
Citation manipulation
Ethical or regulatory concerns
Undisclosed conflicts of interest
If a reviewer suspects misconduct, the concern should be communicated confidentially to the Handling Editor. Reviewers should normally avoid making direct accusations of misconduct in comments intended for authors. Ethical concerns should instead be reported to the editor so that they can be assessed through the journal's established procedures.
Conducting the Review
The review should provide a fair, objective, evidence-based, and constructive assessment of the manuscript. Reviewers should focus on the scientific content of the submission rather than the identity, nationality, institutional affiliation, seniority, gender, or other personal characteristics of the authors. Comments should be professional and respectful. Personal criticism, dismissive language, or inappropriate remarks are not acceptable. Reviewers should assess the following areas where relevant.
Originality and Significance
Consider whether the manuscript:
Addresses a meaningful scientific question
Makes an original contribution to mycology
Provides significant new data, interpretations, records, taxa, or insights
Adds substantially to existing knowledge
Is relevant to the scope of MycoIndia
For biodiversity and taxonomic studies, reviewers should consider whether the findings contribute meaningfully to knowledge of Indian fungi or have broader relevance to fungal systematics, ecology, biogeography, conservation, or related areas.
Study Design and Methodology
Consider whether:
The research question is clearly defined
The study design is appropriate
Sampling methods are suitable and adequately described
Experimental procedures are scientifically sound
Controls are appropriate where relevant
Statistical or analytical methods are suitable
Methods are described with sufficient detail to permit evaluation and reproducibility
Limitations in methodology have been appropriately acknowledged
Results and Data
Consider whether:
Results are presented clearly and accurately
Tables and figures appropriately represent the data
Statistical analyses are correctly interpreted
Data are sufficient to support the principal conclusions
Important negative or contradictory findings have been appropriately addressed
Results are clearly distinguished from interpretation
Reviewers should identify any inconsistencies between the text, tables, figures, supplementary files, or datasets.
Discussion and Conclusions
Consider whether:
The discussion appropriately interprets the findings
Results are placed in the context of relevant literature
Alternative explanations are considered where necessary
Conclusions are supported by the evidence
Claims are not overstated
Limitations of the study are adequately recognized
Broader implications are presented appropriately
Taxonomy and Nomenclature
For manuscripts involving fungal taxonomy, nomenclature, or the description of new taxa, reviewers should assess, where applicable:
Adequacy of morphological descriptions
Quality of photographic and microscopic evidence
Appropriateness of comparative material
Identification of closely related taxa
Adequacy of molecular and phylogenetic evidence
Reliability of sequence data
Sampling of appropriate reference taxa
Quality of phylogenetic analyses
Availability of sequence accession numbers
Deposition of type and voucher specimens
Deposition of living cultures where appropriate
Compliance with relevant nomenclatural requirements
Registration of new fungal names where required
Accuracy of nomenclature, author citations, and typification
Descriptions of new taxa should be supported by sufficient evidence to distinguish them reliably from related taxa.
Molecular Phylogeny and Sequence Data
For studies involving molecular data, reviewers should consider whether:
DNA markers are appropriate for the taxonomic or phylogenetic question
Sequence quality appears adequate
Reference sequences have been appropriately selected
Alignments and phylogenetic methods are suitable
Model selection and analytical parameters are adequately reported
Support values are appropriately interpreted
GenBank or equivalent accession numbers are provided where required
Phylogenetic conclusions are consistent with the underlying data
Reviewers should raise concerns where sequence identification, contamination, taxon sampling, or analytical methodology may substantially affect the conclusions.
Ecological and Biodiversity Studies
For ecological, biogeographical, or fungal diversity studies, reviewers should consider:
Adequacy of sampling design
Geographic and temporal coverage
Replication
Environmental variables
Statistical methodology
Identification methods
Sampling biases
Appropriate interpretation of diversity measures
Strength of conclusions concerning distribution, ecology, or conservation
Claims of new geographic records should be supported by reliable identification and adequate documentation.
Clarity and Presentation
Reviewers should consider whether the manuscript is:
Clearly written
Logically structured
Scientifically understandable
Concise without omitting essential information
Supported by appropriate tables and figures
Consistent in terminology
Correct in the use of scientific names and taxonomic conventions
Reviewers are not expected to provide extensive language editing. However, significant problems affecting clarity or scientific interpretation should be identified.
References
Reviewers should assess whether:
Relevant literature has been appropriately cited
Important previous studies have not been omitted
References are relevant to the claims being made
Citations are used accurately and fairly
Excessive self-citation or citation manipulation is absent
Reviewers should not request citation of their own work unless the citation is genuinely relevant and necessary for the scientific context of the manuscript.
Structuring the Reviewer Report
A clear and well-organized review is valuable to both the editor and the authors. Reviewers are encouraged to structure their reports as follows.
1. Summary
Begin with a brief summary of:
The main objective of the study
The principal approach or methodology
The major findings
The significance of the work
This section may also briefly state the reviewer's overall assessment of the manuscript's scientific contribution.
2. Major Comments
Major comments should address substantive issues that could affect the validity, reliability, interpretation, or publication suitability of the manuscript.
Examples include:
Problems with study design
Insufficient sampling
Inappropriate analytical methods
Unsupported conclusions
Major taxonomic or nomenclatural concerns
Inadequate phylogenetic evidence
Missing essential data
Problems affecting reproducibility
Major inconsistencies between results and conclusions
Major comments should be specific and, where possible, explain how the issue might be addressed.
3. Minor Comments
Minor comments may address issues that do not fundamentally affect the principal conclusions but would improve accuracy, presentation, or readability.
Examples include:
Clarification of terminology
Typographical errors
Minor inconsistencies
Improvements to figures or tables
Formatting problems
Missing references
Small corrections to scientific names
Improvements in wording or presentation
Where possible, reviewers should refer to specific page and line numbers.
4. Confidential Comments to the Editor
Reviewers may provide confidential comments to the Handling Editor when necessary.
This section is particularly appropriate for:
Suspected misconduct
Undisclosed conflicts of interest
Serious ethical concerns
Confidential assessments relevant to the editorial decision
Concerns that should not initially be communicated directly to the authors
Confidential comments should not substantially contradict the scientific assessment provided to the authors unless there is a legitimate reason.
5. Recommendation
Reviewers should provide one of the journal's available recommendations.
Typical recommendations include:
Accept - The manuscript is scientifically sound and suitable for publication, subject only to minor editorial corrections.
Minor Revision - The manuscript is potentially suitable for publication after relatively limited corrections or clarifications.
Major Revision - Substantial changes are required before the manuscript can be reconsidered. A recommendation of major revision does not imply eventual acceptance.
Reject - The manuscript contains significant scientific, methodological, ethical, or scope-related concerns that are unlikely to be resolved through revision. The recommendation should be supported by the reasoning provided in the review report.
Reviewer Recommendations Are Advisory
Reviewer recommendations are an important component of the editorial process but are advisory rather than determinative. The final editorial decision is made by the journal's authorized editor after considering:
Reviewer reports
The Handling Editor's assessment
The authors' responses
The scientific quality and relevance of the work
Ethical and publication-policy considerations
Editors are not required to follow the recommendation of any individual reviewer.
Reviewing Revised Manuscripts
Reviewers may be invited to evaluate a revised version of a manuscript. When reviewing a revision, reviewers should assess:
Whether the authors have adequately addressed previous comments
Whether revisions have introduced new problems
Whether explanations for changes not made are scientifically reasonable
Whether the revised conclusions remain supported by the evidence
Reviewers should avoid introducing extensive new requirements during subsequent rounds unless these arise directly from the revisions or concern important scientific issues that were previously overlooked.
Timeliness
Timely peer review is important for authors and editors. Reviewers should return reports within the deadline specified in the invitation. If additional time is needed, reviewers should contact the Editorial Office or Handling Editor as early as possible.
Recognition of Reviewers
MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi recognizes the important contribution of peer reviewers to scholarly publishing. The name of the Handling Editor may be disclosed with the final published article. Reviewer names may also be acknowledged alongside the published article only with the explicit consent of the individual reviewer and in accordance with the journal's peer-review policy. Reviewers who prefer to remain anonymous will have their identities kept confidential.
Reviewer Independence
Reviewers should provide their assessment independently. They must not allow personal relationships, institutional interests, professional competition, ideological disagreements, or other external considerations to influence their scientific evaluation. Reviewers should not attempt to influence authors to cite particular publications for the purpose of increasing citations to themselves, colleagues, institutions, or particular journals.
Acknowledgment
MycoIndia sincerely appreciates the expertise, time, and professional service provided by its peer reviewers. Rigorous, constructive, and ethical peer review is essential to the journal's mission of advancing reliable knowledge of fungi, particularly the diversity, taxonomy, systematics, ecology, biology, and conservation of fungi associated with India.
Editorial Office: Dr. Belle Damodara Shenoy, Managing Editor, MycoIndia Journal of Indian Fungi, CSIR-NIO Regional Centre , 177/1, Opposite Radission Blu Resort, Yendada, Visakhapatnam - 530045, Andhra Pradhesh, India
Reviewer contact: contact.mycoindia@gmail.com
Website: https://www.mycoindia.org/